ERROR: SSH agent has too many keys
Unfortunately, SSH doesn’t produce this error, although it darn well should…
I just had a Github customer report that they couldn’t access their repos via SSH, despite it all working properly yesterday, and “not having changed anything”. A bit of debug logging and an inspired leap of intuition on the part of another sysadmin in the office, and the answer was quickly found.
First off, the symptoms:
- Debug logging showed that the user was connecting successfully, presenting six SSH keys (none of which were the key of interest) before disconnecting;
- The SSH key was in the user’s SSH agent (you can verify this with a quick ssh-add -l);
- There were more than six keys in the SSH agent
This last symptom is the key point. As an anti-brute-force measure (I assume), SSH won’t allow a user to connect and present more than MaxAuthTries credentials (whether they be passwords or keys) before being forcibly disconnected. The default value for this parameter (if you haven’t realised already) is six.
Whilst this makes a lot of sense for passwords (and a lesser, but still valid, measure for keys) it does mean that you effectively have a hard limit of six keys in your agent simultaneously (at least without using SSH configs to specify a single key to present to the server). Any more than six keys, and you run the very real risk that the key you need to give to a particular server will be number seven in your agent, and all your authentications will fail miserably.
Bumping the value of MaxAuthTries to a much larger value works fine for Github — password auth is disabled, and if you can manage to brute force a key you’re welcome to what you can get — but you certainly can’t rely on inflating MaxAuthTries everywhere to get you out of trouble, so: keep those SSH agents lean, or at least specify IdentityFile for all your servers.
Tags: authentication failure, github, SSH