Remember the good old days, when Melissa and ILOVEYOU were the major virus threats, spreading via e-mail and causing all sorts of embarrassing conversations at work? Or maybe even earlier than that, when the only way you could get a virus was by engaging in risky sex? (I mean Software EXchange, of course… get your mind out of the gutter)

These days, anti-virus protection for e-mail is fairly thorough, and nobody’s really swapping floppies full of 16 colour games at recess. Malware authors have moved on to new and more fertile ground — embedding their junk in web pages, and relying on browser exploits to gain access to computers. Of course, with this method, you can only get infected if you actually visit a page that has an infestation, so the malware authors have two options: either entice you to visit their sites, or modify existing websites that users will visit in the course of their day — legitimate sites that people know and trust, but with a little added infection.

Enticing people to a whole dodgy site is usually just a matter of providing something people love to look at and sticking it in search engines. Since the attacker has to have a stable, identifiable presence for the search engines to direct users to, that can also be used by anti-malware lists like stopbadware.org to protect web users, so this isn’t a particularly effective means of attack, and is waning somewhat in popularity. Far more effective is infecting a legitimate website with some form of malware. How does it happen, though? In our experience, there are four vectors for infection:

1. Brute-force password guessing, where the attacker has a botnet they control to just repeatedly try lots and lots of usernames and passwords. They’re bound to get lucky sooner or later.
2. Some sort of web-based exploit, typically a vulnerability in the web application that allows the attacker to run code of their choosing; this is then either used directly to edit files, or bootstrapped into sufficient access to edit files via another method.
3. Password “scraping”, where the attacker gets direct access to the FTP password for your site. This can either be some sort of malware on the workstation of the web developer (or someone else related to the management of the website) that gets the password off the local machine (in a saved password file, or via a keylogger), or else via the “lost password” functionality provided by the hosting provider. Once the attacker has the FTP password for the site, they are free to login to the live site and make whatever changes they like.
4. Direct modification of the website code on the client-side computer, relying on the developer not to notice it and then upload the compromised content to the live site. We recently had our first “confirmed” case of this (where the web developer found the malicious modifications in their local copy), and they swear blind they didn’t download the HTML from the live site (which would bring the “infection” onto the local machine from the infected live site — which we’ve seen before, and categorise under vectors 1 and/or 2).

The countermeasures required to combat all these vectors boil down to a few simple precautions.

• Use strong passwords. (Protects against vector 1) Yes, they’re a pain to manage, but a weak password is just an open invitation to getting repeatedly and painfully owned. Of course, the strongest password is a keypair, which leads us to…
• Don’t use FTP. (Protects against vectors 1 and 3) The list of reasons for this is long, but for securing your website, FTP is a pain because you can only use passwords[1]. Switch to using SFTP (the file transfer component of the SSH protocol) and you can use public keys, which are, for all practical purposes, unguessable. You should also encrypt your keys with a passphrase, which means that even if the attacker does get access to your workstation and copies the key, it’ll be useless to them — unless they keylog your passphrase, which brings us to…
• Keep your workstation secure. (Vectors 3 and 4) It seems that attackers have realised that the weakest link in the website security chain is still the Windows desktop, and they’re increasingly hitting it as the first step in taking over websites (if you get the right workstation, you can get the credentials to hundreds or thousands of websites, because one web developer often works on many different sites). So, on any machine you connect to webservers from, you need to be doubly, triply sure that it’s rock solid — and that’s just a matter of following all the good advice out on the web. Antivirus, antispyware and firewall software, constantly running, well-configured, and kept up to date; keep up to date with your application patches, especially for your web browser, e-mail client, and core OS; don’t visit dodgy web sites; and so on.
• Protect your e-mail. (Vector 3) If someone can get access to your e-mail, they can also get access to your website, by using the password recovery feature (or impersonating you to your hosting company). If they delete the e-mails that are coming in before you notice them, you’ll never know what’s going on, and all the password changes and workstation security in the world won’t help you.
• Don’t use shared hosting. (Vectors 1 and 3). This might seem an odd thing to say, given that we sell shared hosting, but it is a legitimate way to reduce your vulnerability. If you use a dedicated server (including a VPS), you (or we) can configure it to only allow logins from certain IP addresses, rather than the entire Internet. This means that even if an attacker does get your password (or SSH key), via brute force or sniffing it off your workstation, they can’t login from their own machine because it won’t have an authorized IP address. On shared hosting, this configuration is impractical, because hundreds of people have legitimate access to the server, from a great many different IP addresses.
• Code responsibly. (Vector 2) It is said that “PHP is great, because its ease of use means that any idiot can produce a security hole — and most of them do”. Whilst this is a little derogatory to the many (several? few? one? PLEASE?) good PHP programmers out there, it is certainly fair to say that the capabilities of many people who write dynamic code aren’t up to the challenge of writing code that is exposed to the extremely hostile conditions that are the public Internet.

  Thus, if you are not familiar with the common security practices and problems with the language or environment that you are developing for, stop right now and go learn a little. There’s plenty of good information out there on the Internet from people who have learnt the lessons the hard way. Celebrate the benefits of literacy by learning from their mistakes rather than having to educate yourself by cleaning up an infected website. If you feel that isn’t something you can commit to, then please, for the sake of the Internet, find someone else to write the code.

• Keep your web applications patched. (Vector 2) Whilst some sites do use custom-built web applications, many sites choose to use a standard CMS or other application to manage their website. This is great, because hopefully someone else is taking a bit of responsibility for the security of the software, but that doesn’t do you any good if you don’t keep it up-to-date. Far, far too many people install a CMS once, then forget about it. Almost all of these applications have a vulnerability at some point, and not keeping them up to date is absolutely fatal, because once a vulnerability is found in a piece of software, an attacker can typically use Google to find all of the publicly-available instances of the vulnerable software, and quickly attack them all.

  This means that you need to keep yourself well-informed of any security updates for your off-the-shelf web applications. Subscribe to a relevant security announcements mailing list, or ensure that your vendor sends them to you. (If your commercial CMS vendor doesn’t have this ability, find a new CMS vendor).

Websites get compromised all the time, by a variety of methods. You should reinforce your defences, lest you’re the next target.

1. The first person to mention Kerberos or other unused-in-practice authentication schemes in a comment gets a free laughing at. If you think SFTP and SCP aren’t supported in widely used web development programs, try finding something that supports GSSAPI…

Tags: attack, FTP, password, security, SSH, vulnerability, website

This entry was posted by matt on Monday, November 23rd, 2009 at 10:47 pm and is filed under FTW. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.